This brings us to the first strategy for exposing the truth behind a narcissist’s lies: debunk the alibi. A narcissist treats criticism and accountability as a threat to the story they’re telling about themselves. Anything that challenges that story is handled as evidence that needs to be neutralized.
Denial is usually their first response: “I never said that” or “That didn’t happen.” Even when there’s clear proof, they’ll try to blame you: “It’s not my fault; it’s because you…” They redirect attention away from what you’re pointing out. If that doesn’t work, they’ll try to make you doubt yourself: “You’re remembering it wrong” or “You’re being too sensitive.” Or they’ll minimize what happened: “It wasn’t that bad” or “You’re exaggerating.” If all those approaches fail, they might move into fading facts — an intentional dilution of reality. They layer in extra details, explanations, and side stories until the original issue loses definition and becomes easier to abandon.
Each of these responses serves the same function: they misdirect attention away from the alibi so that it never has to be clearly examined. The moment you see attention being pulled away from the alibi, your job is to put the attention back on the details of the alibi. Instead of reacting like a target, think like a detective: slow the story down, reconstruct what happened, and ask for specific details. Say something like, “Where were you when that happened?” or “Who was there with you?” or “What time was that?” An honest person can answer specific questions because they’re recalling something that actually happened. The details already exist in memory, so walking through them doesn’t feel threatening. If they don’t remember something, they can say so directly without needing to protect a story.
A narcissist can’t do that because the details threaten their image — their image is their self-preservation. When you press for specifics, you’re not just questioning a story; you’re putting their survival system at risk. If the alibi collapses, they will feel exposed, diminished, and in danger of losing control over how they’re seen. That’s why they’re likely to deflect, escalate, or try to move your attention elsewhere.
Phase 2 — Remove attention
Once a detective has questioned a suspect and tested their story, they don’t keep pressing; they leave the suspect alone in the interrogation room. The questioning stops. There’s no reassurance, no validation, no reaction. The suspect is left without feedback. The emotional equivalent with a narcissist is withdrawing your attention.
One of the main reasons narcissists lie is to keep you involved — to keep your time, attention, and energy directed at them. This attention supports their self-image and keeps it intact. Without it, their sense of self destabilizes; they feel exposed and unsettled. So they will try to regain engagement. This is what narcissistic supply is: your attention, your emotional reactions, and your involvement — praise, sympathy, anger, explanation, reassurance, and even compliance. As long as you’re responding, their story stays supported.
When you stop responding, they’re left alone with the narrative, and different lies will appear. They might exaggerate achievements or invent successes to get praise. They might play up their own problems to get sympathy. They might make accusations to get your attention or fabricate urgency and emergencies to make you respond. These are all attempts to pull your attention back so they don’t have to sit alone with the story.
This is where you apply the equivalent of leaving the interrogation room: end the discussion. Walk away or refuse to engage with the lie. You can also gray rock — stay neutral with very short, non-emotional responses. Speak and act like a gray rock: use a flat tone and minimal body language. Do not give energy, reassurance, or arguments; do not explain or defend.
continue reading on the next page
Sharing is caring!